Posts

Showing posts from May, 2025

Einstein's unproductive years- genius undermined by myth.

Image
In a study engagement, I was asked to write on the assertion that "many scientists believe Einstein contributed almost nothing of importance to physics for almost 20 years". I revisited the book on Einstein  I had gifted 23 years earlier to my pregnant wife. It was from the street book sellers near CSTM in Mumbai. The book has aged as have I. The young man it was intended for has chosen to pursue Quantum physics and the purpose of the book has reached it destination.  At such a juncture, such a philosophical question has presented a new leash of life to the content of an old book and a possible fresh journey ahead. I am thrilled to answere this question with my views and as I was reading the authors perspective, many more philosophical queries cropped up. Gemini helped get me some reference extract but a conceptualization is a personal effort. Avon publishers- Ronaldo Clarke 1984. Voluminous and often dull in rhetoric, catalogues in a non f...

Satkhyāti - Notes

Image
The Satkhyāti of Vishishtadvaita: A Theory of Truth and Error In Vishishtadvaita Vedanta, the concept of Satkhyāti plays a crucial role in explaining the nature of knowledge, truth, and error. It distinguishes itself from other prominent theories of error, like Akhyāti (non-apprehension) of the Nyaya school, Anyathākhyāti (apprehension of something as something else) of the Bhatta school of Mimamsa, and most importantly, Anirvacaniyakhyāti (inexplicable apprehension) of Advaita Vedanta.   Satkhyāti, meaning "the apprehension of the real," posits that all knowledge, even erroneous perception, is ultimately grounded in reality. It doesn't deny the existence of error but offers a unique explanation of how it arises, anchoring it in the inherent truthfulness of all cognition. The Nature of Knowledge in Vishishtadvaita epistemology emphasizes the inherent validity of all cognition (prāmāṇya). Every act of knowing is considered intrinsically true unless and until...

Evolvability - An essay

Image
Richard Dawkins' essay on "Evolvability" in the book "Life" explores the idea that evolution itself can evolve, becoming more efficient or capable of generating novel adaptations. Dawkins is more famously known for works like "The Selfish Gene" or "The Blind Watchmaker," but the concept of evolvability is central to his work. Beyond Simple Adaptation- While natural selection drives organisms to adapt to their immediate environment, Dawkins suggests that there's a deeper level of evolutionary "design" that allows future adaptation to happen more readily. This isn't about adapting to a specific niche, but about being able to adapt at all. The "Good Design" of Evolution- Dawkins argues that living systems are structured in ways that facilitate future evolutionary change. This might involve modularity, developmental plasticity, genetic residency and duplication and other novel concepts elaborate...

Back Cover- A motivation to sustain with.

I was intrigued by the back cover picture and the selected quote.  The back cover print of the book ' The Victim is always the same ' presents a metaphorical and reflective take on the themes of the book. there is a calmth in its motionless greenery dominated by the large trunk of a tree occupying the centre space. The dominant image is an abstract representation that evokes a sense of nature and resilience. It appears to be a vertical form, perhaps suggesting a figure or a pathway, flanked by textured, organic shapes in shades of green and brown. The central part has a lighter tone, possibly representing a source of light or a clearing. The overall impression is one of growth emerging from a somewhat rugged or challenging environment. It doesn't directly depict a medical scene but leans towards symbolic representation. Below the image is a quote attributed to the Preface of the book. It reads:    "I should have wished to write a poem had I been able, for perhaps in po...